deadeye... I prefer the GHG shells because of the sleeper head positions as I usually run them in my spread when its real cold or hunting on ice. But I am running them with fullbodies, so you might prefer something that provides more feeder positions... its all a personal preference.
Another shell I didn't see in your poll were the G&H shells. I would consider them as well as they are extremely durable, paint does not come off, and pack together very nicely. I have a couple dozen G&H magnum shells that still look great after being used for the past 12 years.
I've seen a lot of Carrylites over the years with a lot of missing paint and I cannot speak towards the Herters as I've never hunted over them. It all comes down to cost, durability, and what you like to see in a deke. For me, its the the sleeper heads and realistic body position of the GHG's, but the next in line for me is the G&H's.